Skip Navigation
Regional News
We were hoping the state would relieve us of the obligation of paying for Medicaid costs altogether.

Counties disappointed, but state legislators say Medicaid relief just a start

Listen to this story
County leaders around the North Country have been asking the state for mandate relief, especially since New York imposed a 2% property tax cap on local governments last year. Their biggest beef is paying for Medicaid. It accounts for the largest percentage of many county budgets, and many county leaders don't think those costs should be their responsibility.

The governor's budget proposal offers some assistance with local Medicaid costs. The administration has been fanning out around the state, trying to sell the plan he released last week. And Cuomo has gotten some support from north country state legislators. But county leaders aren't as pleased.

Hear this

Download audio

Share this

Explore this

Reported by

Julie Grant
Reporter and Producer

As Essex County manager Dan Palmer listened to Governor Cuomo deliver his budget address last week, he had high hopes. His county is paying nearly seven million dollars toward Medicaid this year.

"We were hoping they’d take over the whole seven million," Palmer said. "In other words, we were hoping the state would relieve us of the obligation of paying for Medicaid costs altogether."

Palmer says the Medicaid mandate is 44% of the Essex County budget. He says it was a big reason they had to over-ride the 2% property tax cap. 

In his speech, Cuomo acknowledged the need to help counties.

"Mandate relief is something everyone wants to do in concept, except no one wants to do when they hear what it really is," the governor said. "Hopefully this year, it’s different."

In total, counties pay eight billion dollars toward Medicaid.   

One bill in the state legislature would have New York taking over all Medicaid costs in eight years. 

Cuomo made it clear, the state won’t be taking over that expense any time soon.

"When we have a printing press, like the federal government, we will take over a program that costs 8-billion dollars," he said. "Until then, we don’t have eight billion dollars."

The costs of Medicaid grow every year.  Back in 2005, the state starting capping those increases. Now, if the costs grow by more than 3% in a year, the state pays the extra. 

But Counties have complained. Their Medicaid costs rise at a 3% rate, but the state has now imposed a 2% tax cap on them.

"We understand the point," Cuomo said. "Hold county’s totally harmless from any increase. This year, so they will be held harmless from all growth in Medicaid.  The state will pick up the cap."

County leaders, such as Dan Palmer in Essex County, were a bit deflated.  No takeover of all Medicaid costs.

"I guess it’s a start," Palmer said. "It’s certainly not what we were hoping for, but maybe in 10-20 years down the road it’s going to start to look good."

Palmer says under Cuomo’s plan Essex County will still be paying about seven million dollars for Medicaid in 10 years. And by then, seven million may be a much smaller percentage of the county budget. But this year, he says it will only save them $60 thousand.

We spoke with Republican State senator Patty Ritchie the afternoon after Cuomo’s speech. She sounded supportive.

"This is a realistic approach, taking over the additional costs," said Ritchie. "At least counties will know what their costs are going to be from one year to the next, so it’s a great way to start."

Republican Assemblyman Ken Blankenbush co-sponsored a bill for the state to takeover all Medicaid expenses. But he wasn’t opposed to the Governor’s more modest proposal.

"We will certainly be looking at that," said Blankenbush. "His proposal, plus our proposal to see if there’s some kind of compromise on that."

Assembly woman Addie Russell used to be a legislator in Jefferson County. I asked her about this after the Governor’s speech:

“I don’t think it’s enough," she said. "I think it’s a great start, you know. It’s going to be dollars that we’re going to see immediate relief without having to do a whole lot of chainging around of how cooutintes do business. I think it’s a great first step but I think mandate relief has to be an ongoing effort.”

Russell says state leaders need to look at other ways to provide mandate relief. She says taking over Medicaid expenses isn’t the only way to assist counties. But with Medicaid costs accounting for almost half of some county budgets, county leaders say it’s the most obvious.

Visitor comments


NCPR is supported by:

This is a Visitor-Supported website.