Skip Navigation
Regional News
Where drillers want to use hydrofracking in New York: pending well permit applications for high-volume hydraulic fracturing. Image: Innovation Trail
Where drillers want to use hydrofracking in New York: pending well permit applications for high-volume hydraulic fracturing. Image: Innovation Trail

More delay possible on hydrofracking

Listen to this story
New York State is facing a Nov. 29 deadline to write rules for the controversial gas drilling method hydraulic fracturing.

If the Department of Environmental Conservation Department doesn't complete its work by that date, the rule making process, possibly including public hearings, would have to start all over again. And a delay in a heath study, which could take months, means that could happen. It could possibly include more public hearings, and add several more months if not years to a review process that's been going on since 2008.

Hear this

Download audio

Share this


Explore this

Reported by

Karen DeWitt
NYS Capitol Correspondent

Story location

News near this location

New York State Health Commissioner Dr. Nirav Shah was assigned the task back in September of compiling a panel of health experts to review data on the health effects of fracking. Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner Joe Martens had decided the additional review was necessary before any decisions on whether to allow fracking in New York State could proceed.
 
Now, with just over two weeks to go until the deadline, a State Department of Health spokesman confirms that the outside experts required for the health review have not yet been hired, and the agreement involving the scope of their work, and any fees they will be paid, has not yet been worked out.
 
Spokesman Bill Schwartz says he can’t "speculate" on whether the health review will be completed or will even begin in the next two weeks.
 
A spokeswoman for the Department of Environmental Conservation could not immediately say whether the November 29th deadline would be met.
 
Members of a growing group of local government leaders who are opposed to fracking say they have a lot of unanswered questions about the new health review. Martha Robertson Chairs the Tompkins County Legislature, which includes the City of Ithaca.
 
"We’d very much like to know what it is actually that Commissioner Martens has asked the Health Department to review," Robertson said. "That has not been made public."
 
Neither the environmental or health agencies have said where the health impact data comes from. It was not part of the original environmental review that’s still being finalized.
 
The local officials met privately for nearly two hours with Martens. They say Martens listened to their concerns, but no decisions were made.
 
Before the meeting, Binghamton Mayor Matt Ryan said he doesn’t believe, no matter how many reviews are conducted, that the gas drilling should ever happen in New York.
 
"Quite frankly I don’t think we’ll ever be ready for this industry and we should go in a different direction," said Ryan, who said clean, alternative energies should be pursued instead.
 
But before any of that can happen, the health review, as well as the environmental impact review on fracking, will need to be completed, and that may not happen until well after the new year.

Visitor comments

on:

NCPR is supported by:

This is a Visitor-Supported website.